I Think Not! Live Tickets

I Think Not! Live brings the sharp wit of Ellyn Marsh and Joey Taranto from the popular I Think Not! podcast to the live stage. This dynamic duo blends Broadway-caliber performance with gripping true-crime storytelling, delivering a show that’s funny, compelling, and consistently entertaining. With Marsh and Taranto at the helm, audiences get an intimate, veteran-led experience that feels like a night out with trusted friends who know how to deliver a story with punchlines and suspense in equal measure.

Hosts & Background: Ellyn Marsh and Joey Taranto are renowned Broadway veterans known for their engaging stage presence and seasoned storytelling. Their collaborative live show—born from the I Think Not! podcast—transforms true-crime anecdotes into theatrical storytelling that’s accessible, energetic, and witty. The production pairs sharp humor with carefully researched narratives, making each performance a unique event for theater lovers and podcast fans alike.

Where to Find Them: The I Think Not! Live team maintains an active presence across social platforms and the official podcast site. Follow along for show updates, behind-the-scenes insights, and tour information directly from the creators.

Social & Online Community: Official hosts page links to Instagram @ellynmarsh and @itsjoeytaranto, and Twitter/X handles @ellynmarsh and @Joey_Taranto. Stay connected with the latest announcements and tour stops at ithinknotpod.com.

Upcoming tour information is announced as dates become available. Each show is treated as a standalone event, offering fans a chance to experience the unique blend of Broadway energy and true-crime storytelling in a live setting. If you’re planning for an I Think Not! Live experience, secure your seats early—these performances tend to sell out quickly given the duo’s devoted following.

Venue & city details accompany every listing, including accessibility information, venue capacity, and nearby lodging options, so you can plan a smooth, stress-free night out. We’ve got you covered with reliable, straightforward ticket access—no fuss, just great seats and a great show.