You got a guy™ for venue tickets

Bay Street Theatre Tickets

Location
Venue Details, Se

Now selling

Upcoming Events at Bay Street Theatre

Loading current ticket availability

The venue

About Bay Street Theatre

Bay Street Theatre is a not-for-profit professional regional theatre located at 1 Long Wharf, Sag Harbor, NY 11963. With a fixed auditorium seating arrangement for 299 guests, the venue offers intimate performances that are easy to navigate from your arrival to the show. The theatre hosts a range of productions, from classic plays to new works, plus educational programs through Literature Live and special events like the annual Summer Gala.

Whether you’re a local resident or visiting the Hamptons, we’ve got you covered with practical details on seating, parking, transit, and nearby lodging and dining options to help you secure your seats with ease.

Bay Street Theatre has a storied history of commissioning and premiering works, including notable titles like By the Sea, By the Sea, By the Beautiful Sea (premiered in 1995). The venue also hosts Literature Live, bringing free student performances and educational programs to the community. For a seamless visit, consider nearby lodging such as The American Hotel, Sag Harbor Inn, and Baron's Cove, and explore affiliate partner recommendations for dining. The theater is conveniently located at the corner of Main Street & Bay Street on the Long Wharf, with multiple parking options and accessible transit via the Hamptons Jitney. Secure your seats in advance and enjoy a performance in Sag Harbor’s historic waterfront setting.

Good to know

Seating, Parking & Venue Information

  • Capacity: 299 seats.
  • Address: 1 Long Wharf, Sag Harbor, NY 11963 (corner of Main Street & Bay Street on the Long Wharf).
  • Venue type: Not-for-profit professional regional theatre.
  • Seating chart: Fixed auditorium seating with rows labeled by letters and seat numbers; virtual tour shows seat layout.
  • Parking: Paid parking (ParkMobile) at the theater front door or municipal lot on Long Island Ave; 2-hour on-street parking; long-term free parking on side streets.
  • Transit: Accessible via Hamptons Jitney; Sag Harbor stop near Main Street/American Hotel within walking distance of the theatre.
  • Nearby hotels/lodging: The American Hotel, Sag Harbor Inn, Baron's Cove, and other Sag Harbor lodging options.
  • Notable events hosted: Literature Live educational programs (free student performances; recent seasons included Fahrenheit 451 in 2025); world premiere and/or commissioning work such as By the Sea, By the Sea, By the Beautiful Sea (premiered at Bay Street in 1995); The Crucible (Literature Live production, 2023); annual Summer Gala events.