You got a guy™ for venue tickets

Playhouse 91 Tickets

Location
Broadway Theater in Upper East Side, NY

Now selling

Upcoming Events at Playhouse 91

No events listed right now

Check back soon, or browse other venues for events near you.

The venue

About Playhouse 91

Playhouse 91 was a charming Off-Broadway theater located at 316 East 91st Street in the Upper East Side of Manhattan. Although the space is no longer operating as a theatre after its closure in 2006 and redevelopment, this page preserves the history and provides practical, insider-style information for theatre lovers and locals exploring the neighborhood. Whether you’re researching past productions like Quartermaine's Terms, After the Fall, Spook House, The Syringa Tree, or Menopause the Musical, or simply planning a visit to the Upper East Side, we’ve got you covered with context about the venue, nearby transit, and nearby lodging and dining options.

For visitors seeking nearby accommodations, dining, and easy transit access, we offer helpful, dependable recommendations and clear guidance to secure your plans in the area.

Venue history and status: Playhouse 91 operated as a small, intimate theatre with a capacity of up to a few hundred seats, contributing to the neighborhood’s cultural scene. The venue closed on May 31, 2006, and the space was reported as sold and redeveloped into a residential project. Today, the building at 316 East 91st Street is a housing development, while the legacy of its productions remains a notable part of the Upper East Side’s theatre heritage.

Location and transit context: Nestled on the Upper East Side, the venue was conveniently situated near multiple subway options. The CityRealty context notes proximity to the 4, 5, and 6 lines within walking distance, making it accessible from across Manhattan and beyond.

Nearby hotels and amenities: Nearby hotel options suitable for theatre patrons and visitors to the area include Courtyard New York Manhattan/Upper East Side, The Marmara Manhattan, and Hotel Wales. While the venue itself no longer operates, these accommodations remain strong choices for guests seeking comfort and proximity to the neighborhood’s cultural offerings. We highlight affiliate partners and easy booking paths to help you secure a convenient stay near the historic site.

What to know when researching this venue: If you’re delving into past shows like Quartermaine's Terms, After the Fall, Spook House, The Syringa Tree, or Menopause the Musical, you’ll find this page valuable for understanding the theatre’s footprint in New York City Theatre History and how the Upper East Side environment supported intimate, artist-driven productions.

Good to know

Seating, Parking & Venue Information

  • Address: 316 East 91st Street, New York, NY 10128.
  • Capacity: 299 seats.
  • Venue type: Off-Broadway theater (Upper East Side, Manhattan).
  • Status: Closed May 31, 2006; space reportedly sold and redeveloped shortly thereafter.
  • Notable productions: Quartermaine's Terms, After the Fall, Spook House, The Syringa Tree, Menopause the Musical.
  • Current status: Building redeveloped into a residential project; the site is now a housing development at 316 East 91st Street and no longer operates as a theatre.
  • Transit (location context): On the Upper East Side; near multiple subway options with a short walk to the 4/5/6 lines (CityRealty listing notes proximity to subways).
  • Nearby hotels (pre-closure context): Several hotels were listed as nearby options for patrons (e.g., Courtyard New York Manhattan/Upper East Side, The Marmara Manhattan, Hotel Wales) per hotel listings referencing Playhouse 91's location.