Two Strangers (Carry A Cake Across New York) Tickets

Dates showing in January 2026 include a Sunday matinee on January 25 at 3:00 PM. The show has wide appeal for fans of contemporary musical theatre, with a London/UK theatre pedigree and a rising Broadway presence that began previews on November 1, 2025 and opened on November 20, 2025.

Seats are available through Telecharge with multiple options: digital lottery at the best available price, in-person rush tickets at the best available price, and previews priced up to the best available price where applicable. The Longacre Theatre provides a comfortable, historic setting at 220 West 48th Street, offering an accessible downtown Manhattan experience for locals and visitors alike.

Celluloid-like intimacy meets lyrical storytelling as Two Strangers takes the stage at the Longacre Theatre. For fans of the London original and the North American premiere, this production promises a strong performance by Sam Tutty and Christiani Pitts. For the best chance at seats, consider entering the Telecharge digital lottery, checking for in-person rush availability, or planning around the theatre’s box-office hours.

Venue details: Longacre Theatre, 220 West 48th Street, New York, NY 10036. The venue sits in the heart of Midtown, convenient to multiple subway lines and local dining—perfect for a post-show stroll or a pre-show meal. Official social handles and the show’s website offer additional cast and performance updates.

For the full experience, follow the cast for updates: Sam Tutty on Instagram and Twitter, Christiani Pitts on Instagram and Facebook. Learn more about the production’s London roots and the London cast recording on the official pages and music label sites: If I Believed Ltd and the London Cast Recording page.