Pen Pals - Play Tickets

Pen Pals - Play runs through March 15, 2026, with multiple performance times listed throughout January, February, and March. Current tickets begin at the best available price, and seating details like great seats in the section you want are available with our secure checkout. Plan ahead to secure your preferred date and seats.

Rotating cast windows offer audiences a chance to see different performers bring the script to life. January 21–February 1 features Randy Graff and Beth Leavel, followed by February 4–15 with Brooke Adams and Marilu Henner, February 18–March 1 with Carmen Cusack and Gina Torres, and March 4–March 15 with Jodi Benson and Marcia Mitzman Gaven. For the latest schedule, check our listings and the venue’s calendar as dates can shift. If you’re planning a visit to NYC theaters, DR2 provides a convenient option for a night of engaging storytelling in a central Manhattan location.

Next performances at DR2 include February 4, 2026 (7:00pm), February 5 (1:00pm), February 7 (3:00pm and 7:00pm), February 8 (2:00pm), with additional dates through March 15, 2026. To secure your seats, we’ll handle the ticketing details and keep you informed about any changes to dates or cast. For performer updates, you can follow the official channels linked below.